Shariff Idd

From WikiIslam

Jump to: navigation, search
Georgics

Miracles
19: The 'miracle' of Islam
Splitting the Moon
Cat's Eye Nebula in the Quran

Animals Marked by Allah
Praying Tree
Allah in the Sky
A Tomato's Shahadah
Honeycomb Allah
Allah's Favorite Fish
Allah in an Egg Plant
Right Hand
Allah in the Ear
Satire:The Miracle of Ankh

10 Meter Tall Human Skeleton
Trees Saying Shahadah
Human Bronchus Makes Shahadah
Shariff Idd
Fake Conversions
Allah's Melons
Cactuses Spell Out Allah

Miscellaneous
Standing Mosques

Articles
Modern Science in the Quran
Islamic Cosmology
Muhammad's Miracles?

According to a huge number of online sources a five year old Kenyan boy (sometimes he's claimed to be Tanzanian or Nigerian) can recite the entire Quran and preach in at least 5 languages. The boy is supposed to have converted thousands of people all over the world.

This article in the Scotland on Sunday seems to be the source for the story circulating one a large number of Islamic websites.

BOY, 5, Converts 1,000 To Islam

There are orphans and street children everywhere. So much so that the sight of another small child standing on a street corner hardly merits a second glance.

But only when a boy opens his mouth to speak do onlookers realize that Shariff Idd is special. The five-years-old speaks in five languages - English, French, Italian, Swahili and Arabic - even though he is completely uneducated.

Shariff is a preacher who draws crowds of thousand in Kenya to his increasingly regular sermons. The Lybian leader, Colonel Muammar Al-Gaddafi, is a great supporter following an audience with him earlier this year. Last week was a milestone for the child introduced to gawping throngs as the "Miracle Boy" of East Africa. He smiled triumphantly when told he had notched up his one thousand conversion to Islam in a country where Muslims are a minority.

Tours of France and Britain now beckon, according to Haji Maroulin, one of the boy's four guardians. He will travel as a missionary on a trip to be financed by a businessman from the Ivory Coast.

"When he is not preaching he is just like any other kid," Haji Maroulin said. "But when he preaches he changes.

At one year old he was able to recite the Quran and went on to be able to preach in Arabic, Swahili and French without any learning. The number of his converts is growing daily." For a child he has strangely adult mannerism. He speaks confidently, mainly in Swahili unless he is delivering a sermon. Then, he fixed his piercing brown eyes on the person he is addressing without inhibition.

His squeaky child-like voice mesmerizes audiences. According to Haji Maroulin, Shariff was born into Swahili-speaking Catholic family in Arusha, north Tanzania, in December 1993: "At the age of two months he refused to suckle his mother's milk and at the age of four months he started reciting verses from the Holy Quran." The boy's first words - "You people repent and you will be accepted by God" were in Arabic. He concerned parents believed him to be disturbed by "demons" and called pastors to pray for the baby.

Eventually Muslim neighbors interpreted their son's alien speech and his parents later converted to Islam themselves. Although his father died in 1997, his mother remains in Tanzania while her worldly son continues his travel. There is no doubting his pulling-power and in a commercial world his entourage has been quick to produce videos of the high-pitched sermons. He has also been deemed genuine by Kenya's Muslim World League.

Kaplich Barsito, 35, from Nairobi, saw Shariff in action addressing a crowd of more than 1,000 in an open area of the Pumwani districts of Kenya's capital, and is in no doubt of the boy's abilities. "He was like a politician, very confident," he said. He seemed as though he would have been disappointed if there had been less people. The power went off and his minders wanted him to stop, but he grabbed the loud-speaker and carried on in Swahili, English and Arabic. It was very impressive and he mesmerized the audience with a focused sermon."

Shariff himself seemed mystified about his powers. He said last week that he picked up languages as soon as he heard. "I went to Congo and heard people speaking Lingala (the local language). I just was able to start speaking it."
Scotland on Sunday, August 8, 1999

Scan of Newspaper Story: Scotland, August 8, 1999

Quite a few miraculous claims. Here's a typical example of how the story is retold by Muslims all over the web.

I have heard that there is a 5 year old sheikh in Tanzania. His name is Sheikh Sharfuddin al Khalifah. I heard that he was born into a Christian or Jewish family and he was a Hafiz of the Quran from birth. He then started praying salaah from the age of one and a half years. He then made his older brother Muslim, and when their parents found out, they were kicked out of the house. When the government heard about this, they were taken into government protection, he has also made many more people Muslims and he gives speeches all around Tanzania and he is only five years old.
Talha at www.sunniforum.com

As we see the story just gets better and better every time Muslims retell it. The boy is now a Sheik and possibly a former Jew(!) and he knew the entire Quran by hearth from Birth. Notice how the evil(!) Jewish (or Christian) parents of the boy kicked him out of the house for converting his older brother. [1]

[edit] Evidence That Using the Kid is a Hoax

The whole Shariff Idd story seems to be an elaborate hoax of sorts. Here's what several Muslims who saw the boy have to say about it:

"I have a video of this one also. And to me it looks like someone has made the boy by heart few Arabic sentences and few verses of the Quran and he always starts off in a high pitch with gestures and all that. Seems like some one is making pretty good business doing this.
muslimonline.org
"He is not the genius he is portrayed to be. His so-called Arabic sermon is just few famous words and duas from khutbahs that are delivered in all mosques. Nothing else. His English, in one instance that he did use English, seemed to have been memorized as he could only say, "Allah, the merciful, beneficent says in the Quran..." and then he stopped English, read the ayah in Arabic and then recited a some duas and that was it. I think it's just exploitation of a little smart child and those who are doing this to him, I suspect, are just trying to make money."
muslimonline.org
"The boy has been taught some verses and that's all. When he is questioned further or asked to recite something different he is bewildered. His father always tries to jump in and answer for him. They had taken him around America at the time of our discussion. He was supposed to have been responsible for thousands of conversions (not necessarily a bad thing). Anyway, maybe someone can hook you up to the old thread?."
muslimonline.org

Even thought Muslims do not disagree with using this kind of trickery to gain new converts he clearly says it like it is: it's a hoax. Also, notice how immediately Christians and Sufis are blamed for hoodwinking Muslims.

"this past summer a brother who attends our tafseer class in Virginia, went to see this "miracle boy" in Philadelphia. The brother told us he is convinced that the entire thing is an elaborate scam done by either the Christians or the Sufis with the intent to hoodwink the Muslims. [...] the Quran reciter on the videotape is NOT the boy. In fact, the video never shows the boy reciting anything from the Quran. [...] Before the boy's entrance, the bodyguards would pass around a collection basket for people to donate money. People were never informed as to what the money they were donating was for or how it would be used. It was apparently assumed the money was for the boy himself, thus many people donated large sums of money. [...] Later when the boy's father was not present, some attendees asked the boy to recite some suras. At first, the boy acted as if he didn't understand what was being asked. The bodyguards appeared irritated and said it was not proper for anyone to order the boy to recite. People replied that they were not ordering anything, but were simply asking IF he could recite SOMETHING so that people could hear him. A translator then asked him to recite some suras such as Ar-Rahman, Al-Mulk, etc. and the boy replied, "I don't know that". They then asked him to recite suratul Ala, to which he replied again, "I don't know that". They then asked him to recite suratul Ihklas, he said, "I don't know that". It then became obvious to everyone that the boy knew nothing of the Quran, and was simply fooling everyone with an elaborate and well-concieved con.

When the father returned and noticed what was going on, he quickly hustled the boy and his bodyguards out of the auditorium. Many attendees felt betrayed, especially when it was discovered that the boy and his "family" left town soon thereafter and their whereabouts were unknown.

If this is a scam, obviously the boy is not to blame, but rather the dajjaleen who are parading him before the Muslims as a pseudo-prophetic persona with the express intent of fleecing masses of Muslims from their money. [...][1]

Here another example of someone who saw him, thought it was all a hoax yet still hopes this deceit would bring new converts to Islam.

"He came to my neighbourhood mosque - Islamic Center of New York - several months ago. Our imam put him in front of the congregation and dispelled alot of myths about him. One of such is that he has not memorised Quran....maybe a sura or two. When asked questions, he answered like a normal little boy. [...] I just remember walking away thinking it was all a fraud. Whatever the case, I just hope he has touched some people and brought them to Islam."[1]

[edit] References

Personal tools
Toolbox